#TellHisStory: Dear God, I Don’t Understand (And a Book Giveaway)

December 9, 2014 | 61 comments

I’m afraid of messing this up.

That’s the thought running through my mind as I recline in the bed next to my daughter, who catapults hard questions into the inky hollowness above us.

I can’t see her tears, but I can hear them. It’s the way her tiny voice wobbles and squeaks. I reach along my side, to find her hand in the dark.

“Why doesn’t God answer my prayers, Mom?” She snaps out the words, like they’re hot, like she has to spit them out before they burn. “Doesn’t He hear me?”

I let out my breath in one steady stream, into the quiet above her polka-dotted comforter, begging silently for some shred of inspiration that I can offer to a 10-year-old girl who is asking the hardest questions.

The only words I can find hover like useless syllables above us: “I don’t know, Lydia. I just don’t know. I don’t know. I don’t.”

I blink back my own tears. I want to offer more. I am her mother, the one she is trusting tonight with the answers. And this is it? A series of “I don’t knows?”

Truth is, I’ve uttered the same questions in those moments when my prayers boomeranged back without the answers I begged for. I’ve pounded my fists into armchairs and bed-pillows and the carpet when God hasn’t acted the way I wanted him to.

I’ve hurled furious questions into the darkness, too. Lydia’s voice wobbles again: “I’m angry, Mom. Sometimes, I’m angry at God. Do you think He’s mad at me when I say that? Will He still love me?”

I turn on my side and rub her cheek. I do know the answer to this one: “God loves you. Always. And Lydia, don’t you ever forget it. You promise? No matter the pain, or the heartache, or the mystery of this world. No matter if you can’t see one step in front of you, or if you can’t make sense of anything behind you, He always loves you. He loved you all the way to the cross and back. And that, my daughter, is a promise I believe with every ounce of my life.”

I keep caressing that soft cheek. And we let the answers hang there awhile.

It’s a bittersweet moment.

Sweet, because this is what I’ve always wanted: honest exchanges about faith with my two daughters. I’ve never wanted them to be ashamed of their questions, or to feel the need to sugar-coat their feelings, or to shellac their ache with cliches´. I’ve only wanted them to be gut-level honest with a God who knows what they’re feeling anyway.

But it’s bitter, too. Bitter because of the pain that led to these honest questions that she casts out into the dark. She’s 10, but she has seen how the unthinkable happens to vulnerable people in a crooked world:

* One of our daughters’ young friends recently died.

* A young Haitian boy we love has been very ill.

* And in two days, Lydia will return to the operating room. Back in April, she had a skin-graft to cover a hole in her eardrum. The surgery failed. And she’s scared to go back.

Here in the dark, she reminds me how we had prayed together, right here in this bed, for a successful surgery. Did God not hear those prayers? That’s the question she wants the unvarnished answer to. And what about when Jesus said that whatever we ask in prayer, if we believe, we will receive?

In moments like these, I freeze on the inside, and I become self-focused enough to think that my words will make or break something. Like, if I say the right or wrong thing, she’ll gain — or lose — another ounce of confidence in her Father.

As if it were entirely up to me.

I am only beginning to learn that it might be OK to whisper a raspy “I don’t know” into the dark. (Especially in these moments when I actually don’t know.) And I’m beginning to wonder if every “I don’t know” carries more light into the dark places than the clichéd answers I’ve picked up along the way.

I’ve also learned to embrace the doubts, because – odd as it might seem – they’ve been the starting blocks in my own race for truth. Many years ago, at a point when I was crippled by doubt, I highlighted these words in my study Bible: “Silent doubts rarely find answers.” Back then, I had just begun to ask questions of myself, and of God. In that exchange, God and I began to develop a relationship of trust. I came to understand that God wouldn’t ostracize or punish me for my questions. Instead, He has been a patient friend, continually keeping the door open for more conversation.

I’ve also learned to invest valuable time looking in the rear-view mirror of my life, reflecting back to see where God’s hand was working all along in places I couldn’t see when my present pain clouded my vision.

And, as Philip Yancey said, “I have learned that faith means trusting in advance what will only make sense in reverse.”

Even in reverse, not everything makes sense right away. We might have to get to heaven before we find out the answers to some of our most pressing questions. For years, I have written some of those unknowns on little slips of paper, filing them in a manila envelope labeled “My Mystery File.”

Lydia’s surgery? Tonight, it feels like Mystery File material. But in three days? It might make total sense. We’ll have to wait and see. That’s what I tell my daughter in the dark.

I tell her we may have to look in the rear-view mirror to see where God was working all along. Until that moment of clarity, it’s okay to say “I don’t know” or “God, I don’t get this.”

Lydia and I are learning that faith has less to do with what we understand, and more to do with what Jesus Christ undertook.

Indeed, personal suffering can lead the thoughts of a believing child and her mama back to a Savior who fully grasped pain at its most unfathomable level. And that part? I do understand. Even if it’s just a small beginning, a little light, enough to see in the dark.

And I think Lydia understands, too – that if Jesus loved us enough to die for us, He won’t abandon us in the middle of our toughest questions.

We say our prayers, and I kiss her goodnight, and we know that even if we don’t have answers when the sun rises tomorrow, we will still have a trustworthy God.

This essay was published in the newly released book, For the Love of God: A Woman’s Guide to Finding Faith and Getting Grace

by Jenny Lee Sulpizio. Used with permission. 


I’m so excited to offer THREE COPIES of For the Love of God

The book is a fresh guide to finding faith. This is the book for any woman who is new to the faith, or for anyone interesting in pursuing a relationship with God. I am thrilled to have today’s blog post published in this new book.

For a chance to win this book, enter using the Rafflecopter below (Email subscribers click here to enter.) I will draw THREE WINNERS on Saturday and notify the winners by email.

a Rafflecopter giveaway

For the Love of God Book Trailer

(Email subscribers: Click here to view)

#TellHisStory Linkup

Share your stories here. Be sure to visit and encourage someone else in the linkup! (Details on the linkup here.)

by | December 9, 2014 | 61 comments


  1. Priscilla

    I have been struggling with my relationship with God. I would appreciate the opportunity to read this book.

  2. jessb

    This post really met me in the middle of my own hard questions. Thank you for faithfully providing these consistent reminders and assurance of how much He loves us and is good to us. It is much needed refreshment and truth when lies tend to scream in our faces all day long. Thanks again for being a willing vessel for Jesus! Your ministry makes a beautiful difference in the world and in my life personally!

  3. Jenny

    Those are hard questions, but grace lies in your honest answer momma. Sometimes the best answer we have is, “I don’t know.” And so we offer our fear, doubts and questions to God instead of our pride because we know all the answers.

  4. Mary

    I love that you have been given the gift of these faith based conversations with your daughter. I can see you both are blessed by this. When my sons were growing up, I did not initiate conversations asking the hard questions about God and the big “whys” in life. I am blessed now to have these conversations with my grown sons. Thank you for the reminder that it might all become clear when we look in reverse.

  5. Katie Reid

    I am glad that He is not afraid of our questions but welcomes them.:)

  6. JViola79

    I love that you have been able to have these conversations with your girls. They truly are the conversations we moms always hold dear in our hearts. Such a hard & heartfelt question. “Faith” was my one word for this year & has proven to be a most challenging & difficult word 🙂 I so loved this —> “Faith has less to do with what we understand, and more to do with what Christ undertook.” AMEN! & thank you for sharing this today! Blessings!

  7. Betsy Cruz

    Such hard questions, but it’s so good to talk them out. God is biger than our questions. We have a friend right now who has gone through so much heartache it’s unbelievable, and it’s been hard for my daughter to grasp. I can definitely relate to this post. Faith is about what He’s already done for us!

  8. Asheritah Ciuciu

    Oh friend, how glad I am that you write with such transparency, even about the I-don’t-know moments of parenting. Truthfully, that’s what I’m most afraid of as my daughter grows up, but you’re right: it’s prideful to think my answers will make or break her budding faith in God. He is bigger than my insecurities and He will be faithful to His work in her, even as He is to me.

  9. Jenny Lee Sulpizio

    Such a beautiful post. So honored to have you in this book, Jennifer. Hugs!

    • dukeslee

      Thank you for the opportunity to share, Jenny. I pray that your book is an encouragement to many women.

  10. June

    A beautiful story, Jennifer, all the more powerful because it’s real and from your heart. You bless so many with your words of faith. Blessings.

    • dukeslee

      I’m glad it blessed you, June. And I’m glad you’re a part of the #TellHisStory community of writers.

  11. KristinHillTaylor

    I love that definition of faith from Philip Yancey. And this whole post just echoes that faith, even when hard things happen. Thanks for the encouragement and sharing this book, which I would LOVE to win. 🙂

    • dukeslee

      Yeah, I love that Yancey quote too. I’ve quoted a few times around here. It sticks.

  12. Jennifer Camp

    I am reminded of my son’s voice just last week, asking the same questions. Yes, I give ‘I don’t knows’ back too. Bless you, Jennifer, as you show your daughters how to cling to God in our weakness and His strength. I so appreciate your beautiful wisdom and encouragement here and would love this book!

    • dukeslee

      Hi Jennifer, Thank you for your encouragement today!

  13. Katie Kump

    Always timely, Jennifer. I’ll be sharing this with the friends who hold my hands when we’re all questioning together. xoxo

    • dukeslee

      Grateful for your heart that hears, and your hands that hold.

  14. Bethany Boring

    I’ve visited this blog SO many times but just linked-up for the first time today. I have bilateral hearing-loss and a “hole” in my right eardrum. I have not been offered the procedure your daughter is undergoing in a few days because my hearing is incredibly unstable at the moment. I am praying for the both of you. I know how hard these procedures can be on both kids and adults (I have a child with bilateral hearing-loss as well). Love your blog. Love your message. Dreams are coming true here everyday.

  15. Bethany Boring

    Oh…and I almost forgot…I’d love to win 3 copies of this book too! 🙂

  16. Anita

    Of course I would love to win! Thank you for sharing this beautiful post. It’s so important to keep it real with our children–to let them know that it’s ok to ‘save up questions for heaven’.

  17. Tania Vaughan

    Great post – I’d love to win and I’m glad to link up with you today 🙂

  18. michellesarabia

    Love this! We may not understand the why’s, but their is comfort is knowing the Who. Sometimes our boomerangs mean we are given a spoon instead to keep stirring until the sauce thickens. *wink*

  19. Karrilee Aggett

    Oh those laying-down-side-by-side truth talks… the ones where we really don’t have the answer, and yet we know the Answer… hard, but vital in growing faith – both ours and theirs! I think in our being open and honest, sharing the fact that we don’t know it all – binds us together even more… because it means we get to learn together and lean on each other and oh how I love and miss those night time prayer times! (And you know me and books! Of course I would love to win!)

  20. Karrilee Aggett

    Oh those laying-down-side-by-side truth talks… the ones where we really don’t have the answer, and yet we know the Answer… hard, but vital in growing faith – both ours and theirs! I think in our being open and honest, sharing the fact that we don’t know it all – binds us together even more… because it means we get to learn together and lean on each other and oh how I love and miss those night time prayer times! (And you know me and books! Of course I would love to win!)

  21. Trudy Den Hoed

    What a blessing to have such open-hearted talks with your daughter! I loved reading this. And I especially loved this line – “Faith has less to do with what we understand, and more to do with what Jesus Christ undertook.” Beautiful. Thank you, Jennifer.

  22. Jolene Underwood

    Goodness yes and Amen. Powerful book trailer. Beautifully touching story. So on board. Yes, yes, and amen again.

  23. Cheryl

    would love to learn more about this idea of faith

  24. Christie

    I really loved this excerpt from the book! My son and i are learning together how to discuss God and prayers and I think this would be an amazing book to help facilitate. Such a moving story too.

  25. Dusty

    Today’s blog was so timely there is no doubt our Lord is watching from above. I just emailed a dear young friend who has Chiari disease. Her daughter was diagnosed first and then she found out that the same issue was the cause of her own pain for many years. She has such a following of friends through this disease as their are very few doctors around the world that will do a brain compression. She hares when she can on a blog also, and is writing a book to try and help others with the process of this illness. She just found out one of her sisters has the same issue also. The book give-away is wonderful and like others, it would be a wonderful addition to my collection; in fact it may be one of the suggestions I make for our next book club reading. But more than anything I would ask that anyone reading this pray for my friend Monica Snyder. Be blessed!

  26. Alicia

    It hasn’t been that long ago that I was mad at God and pretty sure that he had abandoned me. I’d love to read this book.

  27. aly d. chase

    Your tender vulnerability gets me every time, my friend. Just yesterday I wrote in my journal, while studying Genesis 37, “I need to remember to look at my future with hindsight.” Needless to say, your words have confirmed this message for the season I am in. I wish I could hug you and your precious girls!

  28. Lynn D. Morrissey

    Sounds like a wonderful and needed book, Jennifer, and I”m glad that this story is in it. I was touched when I first read it–deeply touched. The Cross. Jesus’ suffering. Whenever I don’t understand the whys of suffering or why He has allowed it, I realize all that He did on the Cross far supercedes it, and that it is the most tangible proof possible that He loves us. He welcomes our questions, our doubts, our angst…..and yet, if He seems silent, one glance at the Cross, speaks love in the loudest, most profound, most immediate way possible…..and it suffices. Love that girl of yours and how she asks, how you listen and offer, and ulitimately how Jesus answers.

  29. Lanissa

    I would love a chance to win! I’m always looking for encouraging books to read!

  30. Kelly Goodman

    I know the perfect person who could benefit greatly from this book! She is definitely going through a season of Job and lots of prayers that seem to be unanswered. Should I win, I will definitely give it to her! (I may have to read it first myself though!) Blessings to you Jennifer!

    • Jenny Lee Sulpizio

      Love this. I just wish I could bless all of you with a free copy!!! How amazing would that be?!!! Bless you, Kelly!

    • Jenny Lee Sulpizio

      Love this. I just wish I could bless all of you with a free copy!!! How amazing would that be?!!! Bless you Kelly!

  31. Chris

    I would love to win this book. I have a friend that could benefit from it.

  32. Prasanta Verma

    So much wisdom here…I am learning these lessons on faith, too; at times it is very hard and painful but like you say– it will make sense in reverse. Trusting Jesus for it all! Bless you!

  33. Kerrie Chamberlain

    Thank you for the offer at a giveaway and for your faithful pouring out of your life to us ladies out here. I love your Love Idol book, and many copies of it now sit on my shelf (by my stack of 1000 Gifts Books) to give away as the “right” ladies come into my life.

  34. marthaorlando

    Such a moving essay, Jennifer, it brought tears to my eyes. I would love to read this book! Blessings!

  35. Lisa L Keck

    This was such a good post. I don’t have anyone in my life who holds my hand in the darkness and tells me, “I don’t know.”

  36. Mindy Whipple

    Beautiful essay that reflects your beautiful heart. I would love an opportunity to read the book!

  37. Loved As If

    This essay is an absolute gem. Thank you so much.

  38. Sophia

    This sounds like a great book that I would give to my 24 year old daughter…needs Christ in her life as we all do! Hope I win!

  39. Michelle Anderson

    I Love the quote from Philip Yancy. This happens to me often, seeing in reverse. I hope and pray the surgery goes well and sticks this time! <3

  40. Beth

    I’d like to win 🙂 thanks for the opportunity for the book, but most of all thanks for sharing your heart 🙂

  41. Jena Cummings Martin

    This book sounds wonderful!! A great gift this Christmas!!

  42. Marni Gallerneault

    When I recommitted to Jesus a few years ago, I told Him this time it’s gotta be real. Thank-you for confirming how so very important it is to just be real! And like you, my doubts have taken me into some amazing revelations.

  43. michelle

    I would like to win. Thank you!

  44. Tiffany

    Jennifer – Your essay spoke truth into my life. Our 11-year-old son has been dealing with a lot of those same “why” questions. We’ve spent many moments in a dark room holding him close and whispering God’s promises of love – no matter what. I know God considers me worthy to raise up this little life on His behalf, but boy oh boy, does it stretch the boundaries of my heart. Thank you for sharing yours.

  45. Brandi

    Thank you for sharing such beautiful words thru your books trailer!! I would love to have a chance to win his encouraging book, but I lay it on the hands of Jesus that these three books would go to the ones He and only He needs them to read it. That he words in this book have purpose for and speak to. So I leave this prayer for those that win this book that your eyes will be open to the grace that Jesus has laid out for you in the pages of this book!! May His loving grace be filling to all those that read this book. Thank you again for sharing your heart on the pages of your book!! May His grace be filling to you as well!

  46. Kathy

    This book is just perfect for a friend who is searching for meaning in her life. I feel that we need to also engage others to give them information that will spark their interest in the things of God.

  47. Paula

    This looks like a great book for many of my friends and me too!

  48. Beth

    Sounds like a lovely book. And your words Jennifer, always beautiful. I am learning to be more and more real with my children. It’s never too late. Blessings.

  49. Karina S. Alvaera

    I seriously would love to win this book!!!

  50. Elizabeth Stewart

    My post this week is also about children and their questions. I think listening and loving is more powerful than knowing all the right answers.

  51. Nancy Ruegg

    Love your idea of the Mystery File, Jennifer. We shouldn’t dismiss our questions as if throwing them away. Every question should be preserved, because who knows? The day may come when a question can be moved from the Mystery File to the Miracle File! And those days are truly euphoric. Also love the Philip Yancey quote–an encouragement to wait, to persevere, and to believe.

  52. Ava Sophie

    I would love to win the book!

    I love the words: ‘if Jesus loved us enough to die for us, He won’t abandon us in the middle of our toughest questions.’ and I needed them… I Think I will need to memorize them, and repeat them to myself…

    Thank you for sharing <3

  53. Carmen Horne

    Jennifer, God was speaking to both of us this week about trust. Beautiful post. ~Carmen

  54. Adrie @ ALittleWife'sHappyLife

    The Philip Yancey quote! I needed that today. I’m shouting and praying and wondering and sobbing… it’s been a busy week, here. But someday, someday I’ll understand all this pain. That’s what I’m trusting.



  1. Mommy, I did NOT put a yogurt in my closet. - […] linking up with my friends Jennifer and […]
  2. Six Steps to Avoid the Holiday Frazzles | Faith Spilling Over... Into Everyday Life - […] up with HollyBarrett’s #TestimonyTuesday, Jennifer Dukes Lee’s #TellHisStory, and Meredith Bernard’s #Woman2Woman […]
  3. The Gift of Surrender and This Week’s Giveaway | Danise Jurado Blog - […] Linked with:  Good Morning Mondays  Coffee for your heart  #TellHisStory […]
  4. Stay-Mostly-Sane-This-Christmas Tips | Ginger's Corner - […] I’m joining in the community with these links today: Coffee for Your Heart and Tell His Story. […]
  5. Have You Gone Missing This Christmas? - You Are My Girls - […] linking with Kristin and Jennifer–make sure you check out Jennifer’s awesome book […]
  6. How To Offer Hope to a Hurting Friend This Christmas: Part 2 - Redemption Diary - […] Linking up with Holly over at Testimony Tuesday, Jennifer Dukes Lee for Tell His Story […]
  7. Days of Joy. Acts of Kindness. - […] Shared with LivingWellSpendingLess, #TellHisStory […]
  8. The Right Light - Katie M. Reid - […] uplift you. Meredith Bernard: Woman 2 WomanKristin Taylor: Three Word WednesdayJennifer Dukes Lee: #TellHisStoryHolley Gerth: Coffee for Your […]
  9. Awakening to purpose - Words of Joy - […] Holley and Jennifer and other like- minded friends as we seek to bring coffee for your heart in the…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Pin It on Pinterest